Conic Sections Question 219

Question: Let S is a circle with centre $ (0,\sqrt{2}). $ Then

Options:

A) There cannot be any rational point on S

B) There can be infinitely many rational points on S

C) There can be at most two rational points on S

D) There are exactly two rational points on S

Show Answer

Answer:

Correct Answer: C

Solution:

[c] The equation of the circle S is $ x^{2}+{{(y-\sqrt{2})}^{2}}=r^{2} $

  • (1) Let the coordinates of any point on this circle be $ (h,k), $ then $ h^{2}+{{(k-\sqrt{2})}^{2}}=r^{2} $

$ \Rightarrow k=\sqrt{2}\pm \sqrt{r^{2}-h^{2}} $

  • (2) Since the above value of k contains a constant irrational number $ \sqrt{2}, $ therefore, the only possible rational value of k is 0.

Hence, $ \sqrt{2}\pm \sqrt{r^{2}-h^{2}}=0\Rightarrow r^{2}-h^{2}=2 $

$ \Rightarrow h=\pm \sqrt{r^{2}-2} $ Thus, we have following cases (i) if $ r^{2}-2 $ is a perfect square, there will be two rational points, viz.., $ (\sqrt{r^{2}-2},0) $ and $ (-\sqrt{r^{2}-2},0) $ on S. (ii) If $ r^{2}-2 $ is not a perfect square, there will be no rational point on S.

$ \therefore $ there can be most two circle through (1, 0),