Coordination Compounds 2 Question 2

2. Complete removal of both the axial ligands (along the $z$-axis) from an octahedral complex leads to which of the following splitting patterns? (relative orbital energies not on scale).

(2019 Main, 12 April I)

<img src=“https://temp-public-img-folder.s3.amazonaws.com/sathee.prutor.images/sathee_image/snip_images_922coaYrZlL6J4JTLMceRA_eePdDDDFZKINJTvL_Fac_original_fullsize_png.jpg"width="380"/>

Show Answer

Answer:

Correct Answer: 2. (a)

Solution:

  1. Complete removal of both the axial ligands (along the $z$-axis) from an octahedral complex leads to the following splitting pattern.

<img src=“https://temp-public-img-folder.s3.amazonaws.com/sathee.prutor.images/sathee_image/cropped_2024_01_16_b4fdca9f34924034e8d8g-262_jpg_height_367_width_442_top_left_y_1303_top_left_x_1415.jpg"width="380"/>

The single electron in the $d _{x^{2}-y^{2}}$ orbital is being repelled by four ligands, while the electron in the $d _{z^{2}}$ orbital is only being repelled by two ligands. Thus, the energy of the $d _{x^{2}-y^{2}}$ increases relative to that of $d _{z _2}$. A more stable arrangement arises when both the $e _g$ electrons pair up and occupy the lower energy $d _{z^{2}}$ orbital. This leaves the $d _{x^{2}-y^{2}}$ orbital empty.

Thus, four ligands can now approach along $+x,-x,+y$ and $-y$ directions without any difficulty as $d _{x^{2}-y^{2}}$ orbital is empty. However, ligands approaching along $+z$ and $-z$ directions meet very strong repulsive forces from filled $d _{z^{2}}$ orbitals. Thus, only four ligands succeed in bonding to the metal. A square planar complex is formed, the attempt to form an octahedral complex being unsuccessful.